Are they required to sing the "AMAZING GRACE"???

I'm kinda confused, some teams sang it, some teams just read it...

were they required to sang it in the first place? can anyone clarify that?...

RaG@zZo wrote:

I'm kinda confused, some teams sang it, some teams just read it...

were they required to sang it in the first place? can anyone clarify that?...

I have a hunch that, YES (it is required) though the editing, i think kinda tricked us into thinking that NO (it's not required) since none of the teams was shown reading such an instruction.

if they are required then is there a penalty to the teams that didn't sing it?...

RaG@zZo wrote:

if they are required then is there a penalty to the teams that didn't sing it?...

yes but AXN knows how smart true blue / raving TARA fans we are and opted to edit / remove that part of instruction but these are my wild guesses though )

RaG@zZo wrote:

if they are required then is there a penalty to the teams that didn't sing it?...

yea, that's weird. I though Allan Wu said teams needed to sing the song, but some teams (like Sunaina and Dimple) just read it over. And I thought they were in trouble because they would face a penalty, and apparently they didn't, hmmmmm

Z-1988 wrote:

RaG@zZo wrote:

if they are required then is there a penalty to the teams that didn't sing it?...

yea, that's weird. I though Allan Wu said teams needed to sing the song, but some teams (like Sunaina and Dimple) just read it over. And I thought they were in trouble because they would face a penalty, and apparently they didn't, hmmmmm

Allan Wu said that??? Oops, gotta fast fwd to that part LOL thx, zee

Probably there was an instruction somewhere on the lyric sheet. Or Allan Wu just had a Freudian Slip

I think it is part of the task to sing the song. Because if not, then why did Hilda and Ivan sang it......and laughed at their singing during the confessionals? I mean, if nobody told you to sing, and knowing that you have no singing voice, will you still break into a song on TV? haha! I doubt it.

Well, Sunaina and Dimple never got penalized because maybe, the producers weren't so strict with that particular task.

hhhmmmm.....

it's not fair if all teams have to sing the song, because although that is one of the most popular songs on the planet, it is related to specific religions, so... i wasn't surprised the indian teams didn't sing...

or did the producers expect the teams to learn to sing first by playing the song on the piano? but then it's another unfair task, especially if nobody could play a piano..

4everblue wrote:

Z-1988 wrote:

RaG@zZo wrote:

if they are required then is there a penalty to the teams that didn't sing it?...

yea, that's weird. I though Allan Wu said teams needed to sing the song, but some teams (like Sunaina and Dimple) just read it over. And I thought they were in trouble because they would face a penalty, and apparently they didn't, hmmmmm

Allan Wu said that??? Oops, gotta fast fwd to that part LOL thx, zee

Same thought. I also heard Allan Wu saying they need to sing it, but the Indian girls didn't receive a penalty.

chin-go wrote:

it's not fair if all teams have to sing the song, because although that is one of the most popular songs on the planet, it is related to specific religions, so... i wasn't surprised the indian teams didn't sing...

or did the producers expect the teams to learn to sing first by playing the song on the piano? but then it's another unfair task, especially if nobody could play a piano..

so the point is, the "singing" part was kinda absurd, hahahaha

I think they thought Sunaina and Dimple were already singing. LOL

The_Siege wrote:

I think they thought Sunaina and Dimple were already singing. LOL

maybe the thought they were rapping, lol

Z-1988 wrote:

The_Siege wrote:

I think they thought Sunaina and Dimple were already singing. LOL

maybe the thought they were rapping, lol

Watched the video again.....Allan said, "they must sing the next clue"

so this is one of those flaws of the production team... not imposing the rules of the race strictly... (similar to the 232 anomaly)...

RaG@zZo wrote:

so this is one of those flaws of the production team... not imposing the rules of the race strictly... (similar to the 232 anomaly)...

and actually, this thing could have been avoided, hmmm

well, that would be unfair to all the teams who sang it..if Allan had said that they have to SING the clue...


but in fairness to the Riches again, one of them really thought Baldwin is a piano.. nice...

jadomingo wrote:

well, that would be unfair to all the teams who sang it..if Allan had said that they have to SING the clue...


but in fairness to the Riches again, one of them really thought Baldwin is a piano.. nice...

hmm, did it have anything to do with the Riches?? hehe

no, the singing has nothing to do with the Riches...

i'm just saying that in relation to the whole task, they were the only ones who perceived that Baldwin is a piano...

Z-1988 wrote:

RaG@zZo wrote:

so this is one of those flaws of the production team... not imposing the rules of the race strictly... (similar to the 232 anomaly)...

and actually, this thing could have been avoided, hmmm

Ragazzo: I firmly believe that she said 272....

Zee: Avoided or given penalty to be fair to the 9 teams who sang it.....

Mai-Siomai wrote:

I think it is part of the task to sing the song. Because if not, then why did Hilda and Ivan sang it......and laughed at their singing during the confessionals? I mean, if nobody told you to sing, and knowing that you have no singing voice, will you still break into a song on TV? haha! I doubt it.

Well, Sunaina and Dimple never got penalized because maybe, the producers weren't so strict with that particular task.

hhhmmmm.....

not again! first michelle, now Sunaina and Dimple.
these inconsistencies should be addressed.
grrrr.....

dexter02 wrote:

Mai-Siomai wrote:

I think it is part of the task to sing the song. Because if not, then why did Hilda and Ivan sang it......and laughed at their singing during the confessionals? I mean, if nobody told you to sing, and knowing that you have no singing voice, will you still break into a song on TV? haha! I doubt it.

Well, Sunaina and Dimple never got penalized because maybe, the producers weren't so strict with that particular task.

hhhmmmm.....

not again! first michelle, now Sunaina and Dimple.
these inconsistencies should be addressed.
grrrr.....

And once again, AXN never bothered to clear these issues! Grrrr!

Mai-Siomai wrote:

dexter02 wrote:

Mai-Siomai wrote:

I think it is part of the task to sing the song. Because if not, then why did Hilda and Ivan sang it......and laughed at their singing during the confessionals? I mean, if nobody told you to sing, and knowing that you have no singing voice, will you still break into a song on TV? haha! I doubt it.

Well, Sunaina and Dimple never got penalized because maybe, the producers weren't so strict with that particular task.

hhhmmmm.....

not again! first michelle, now Sunaina and Dimple.
these inconsistencies should be addressed.
grrrr.....

And once again, AXN never bothered to clear these issues! Grrrr!

by "not bothering" it, maybe we can say that AXN admits that mistakes?? hahahaha

Mai-Siomai wrote:

Z-1988 wrote:

RaG@zZo wrote:

so this is one of those flaws of the production team... not imposing the rules of the race strictly... (similar to the 232 anomaly)...

and actually, this thing could have been avoided, hmmm

Ragazzo: I firmly believe that she said 272....

Zee: Avoided or given penalty to be fair to the 9 teams who sang it.....

yea, exactly. The rules should be strict and there should be some kind of penalty for not obeying them